If you would like to help keep this site going please
AS THIS IS A FREE FORUM ADVERTS FROM THE SERVICE PROVIDER APPEAR TO THE RIGHT OF THIS NOTICE AND THEY ARE NOT CONNECTED TO THIS SITE.
Services Menu
PURCHASE BOOKS DISCUSSEDIf you have heard about a book in this forum and would now like to read it yourself Astrodene has brought together links to purchase them. Links are available for the UK, USA, Canada, Austalia and New Zealand
ASSOCIATED WEB SITE
ARTICLES OF WAR (Forum rules)
FUTURE RELEASES CALENDAR
IMAGES GALLERY
VIDEO CHANNEL
SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER
Similar topics
Search
Latest topics
Latest News on the Web Site
Loading...
Use of Cookies
By using this site, you agree we can set and use cookies. For more details of these cookies and how to disable them, see our cookie policy.Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
+9
jkeffer
MikeThompson
80 Winters
captain yogi
leonidas
Joolz
conaghan
Alaric Bond
Astrodene
13 posters
Page 1 of 2
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
I enjoyed this series the underlying theme of working for the navy's secret department was interesting and the occasional insights into the working of Trinity House
Last edited by Astrodene on Sun 25 Oct 2009, 12:12; edited 1 time in total
A brig of war
Just started this, my first Woodman for many years. Look forward to leaving a full review shortly.
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
My local library happened to have books 6 through 13 of Woodman's Drinkwater series - - enjoyed all of them very much. Now I have to purchase the rest!
conaghan- Masters Mate
- Log Entries : 96
Location : Republic of Northern Virginia
Joined : 2009-05-08
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
Finished Brig of War and found it stimulating and enjoyable. I especially liked the interplay between the commander and first officer (Drinkwater), and the long term animosities with friends and foe alike came over well.
True to my perverse nature I am now starting on A Kings Cutter; the prequel...
True to my perverse nature I am now starting on A Kings Cutter; the prequel...
A King's Cutter
Another enjoyable book; this time with a little more “history” worked in. I enjoyed the meetings with Duncan, and the description of Camberdown was excellent. Woodman also conveys the purpose (and cramped conditions) of a cutter well. The only slightly inconsistent passage concerned the suppression of mutiny towards the end of the story – I don't want to go into spoilers, but felt that Drinkwater's actions were not in line with his personality. One I will doubtless read again, however (my measure of the value of any book) and, true to form, I'm now looking around for the prequel...
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
Love Drinkwater, especially his east coast and Trinity House connections. I only had the first 3 for many years, but recently completed the collection and am working my way through them.
Seems a little under-rated around here?
Seems a little under-rated around here?
Joolz- Master
- Log Entries : 145
Location : UK
Joined : 2011-07-12
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
Just to set the record straight, my above post gives an erroneous impression - I had a complete set of Drinkwater, my third after Hornblower & Aubrey, but circumstances left me with just the first three for several years. However, I recently completed the set again via omnibus editions, of which the final volume incorporates 2 additional short stories and an overview by the author. I have also replaced my old discoloured Hornblowers with omnibus editions which are excellent value IMO.
Joolz- Master
- Log Entries : 145
Location : UK
Joined : 2011-07-12
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
Just finished the first two Drinkwater novels. Good reading and interesting to get bits of the wider world outside the ships.
Nathaniel sounds a bit like a beserker in the close combat sequences, and almost too good as a sailing master.The Ushant escape was hair-raising.
Have the next four to read and will then seek out others in the series
Recommended reading and more than a touch of O'Brian at times!
Nathaniel sounds a bit like a beserker in the close combat sequences, and almost too good as a sailing master.The Ushant escape was hair-raising.
Have the next four to read and will then seek out others in the series
Recommended reading and more than a touch of O'Brian at times!
leonidas- Midshipman
- Log Entries : 154
Age : 80
Location : Marlborough, New Zealand
Joined : 2011-08-20
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
I shall have to try this series. At the beginning of it all,is Drinkwater a Midshipman?
captain yogi- Able Seaman
- Log Entries : 8
Location : Leeds, England
Joined : 2011-08-30
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
He iscaptain yogi wrote:At the beginning of it all,is Drinkwater a Midshipman?
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
Great mail day. Three omnibus editions of Drinkwater series arrived from 3 different sources in the same delivery!
And another couple of Dewey Lambden novels. Will keep me going for days!
Have read the first six of the Drinkwater novels and thoroughly enjoyed every one. Highly recommended.
And another couple of Dewey Lambden novels. Will keep me going for days!
Have read the first six of the Drinkwater novels and thoroughly enjoyed every one. Highly recommended.
leonidas- Midshipman
- Log Entries : 154
Age : 80
Location : Marlborough, New Zealand
Joined : 2011-08-20
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
I have just finished reading Ebb Tide. Oh dear, I guess I should have expected what happened from the title.
Still a great little vignette of a highly likeable character. Richard Woodman is to be congratulated on a first class series, that never palled or fell below the initial standard he set. His love of the sea has enhanced my own.
Still a great little vignette of a highly likeable character. Richard Woodman is to be congratulated on a first class series, that never palled or fell below the initial standard he set. His love of the sea has enhanced my own.
leonidas- Midshipman
- Log Entries : 154
Age : 80
Location : Marlborough, New Zealand
Joined : 2011-08-20
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
Having had time to reflect on the Drinkwater novels and read Woodman's account of the evolution of the series, I have decided to rate them as second only to the Aubrey novels of Patrick O'Brian.
The characters and stories are credible for the most part, historically "accurate" as far as fiction can be, and each one is a page-turner, which is in my book, a fine signal.
I will definitely be reading them again, but lots of others in the meantime!
The characters and stories are credible for the most part, historically "accurate" as far as fiction can be, and each one is a page-turner, which is in my book, a fine signal.
I will definitely be reading them again, but lots of others in the meantime!
leonidas- Midshipman
- Log Entries : 154
Age : 80
Location : Marlborough, New Zealand
Joined : 2011-08-20
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
Since I selected Richard Woodman as my favorite HNF author in "the poll", and briefly stated "why", I'll use this venue to expand my thoughts on Nathaniel Drinkwater. As stated previously, I "personally" believe it likely that Nathaniel could well be Richard Woodman's "alter ego" (both share long, and not easy, careers as they advanced in the RN, both were long associated with Trinity House, and both were "Tarpaulin Officers" (again, my personal belief).
This was the 1st "Complete" series that I read. My definition of complete being that it was written in order from start to finish (unlike Hornblower) and the author lived to finish it (unlike O'brian, Pope and others). I feel these factors led to "the flow" of the story and while I felt I'd lost a friend as I finished EBB TIDE I also felt "closure".
Woodman is a product of the English "public school system" and again, "I feel personally" that you can't do better when it comes to writing HNF of the RN. (Yes, I still like Dewey Lambdin's series (and others who didn't learn to write in the English PSS, but it's a totally diferent "style"and reflects a different education of the writer).
Like Hornblower, Nathaniel Drinkwater is continually "soul searching" and critiquing his thoughts and behavior..........his "humanity" is there, and I personally have experienced it and many of the characters who "cross those pages".........I too have met in passing. And I'll bet many of you have too.
This was the 1st "Complete" series that I read. My definition of complete being that it was written in order from start to finish (unlike Hornblower) and the author lived to finish it (unlike O'brian, Pope and others). I feel these factors led to "the flow" of the story and while I felt I'd lost a friend as I finished EBB TIDE I also felt "closure".
Woodman is a product of the English "public school system" and again, "I feel personally" that you can't do better when it comes to writing HNF of the RN. (Yes, I still like Dewey Lambdin's series (and others who didn't learn to write in the English PSS, but it's a totally diferent "style"and reflects a different education of the writer).
Like Hornblower, Nathaniel Drinkwater is continually "soul searching" and critiquing his thoughts and behavior..........his "humanity" is there, and I personally have experienced it and many of the characters who "cross those pages".........I too have met in passing. And I'll bet many of you have too.
80 Winters- Rear-Admiral of the Blue
- Log Entries : 2083
Age : 84
Location : Port Townsend, WA
Joined : 2012-03-09
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
I've only read the first of the series, but I really enjoyed it. I'm looking forward to continuing through the rest. Drinkwater's character was really brought out and I'm hoping to see it develop as I delve further.
MikeThompson- Able Seaman
- Log Entries : 9
Age : 71
Location : North Carolina
Joined : 2012-03-07
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
Mike, I look forward to hearing your thoughts on this series as you continue to read and then finish it.
80 Winters- Rear-Admiral of the Blue
- Log Entries : 2083
Age : 84
Location : Port Townsend, WA
Joined : 2012-03-09
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
I have just picked up my first Drinkwater novel, The Corvette. Can't wait to get into it!
jkeffer- Master
- Log Entries : 135
Age : 61
Location : Jacksonville, FL
. :
Joined : 2013-02-25
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
James -
Far be it from me to tell anybody 'not to read Woodman' (after all, he's still my 'favorite author'). However, you're entering a 14 book series at the 5th book. The 1st book in the Nathaniel Drinkwater series is An Eye of the Fleet written in 1981.........trust me, this is where you want to start. Like so many of the 'classic' series, they are 'chronological'.
If you can't find the entire series at your library, I have a set of paperbacks listed under the 'books to loan' thread. Check it out.
Far be it from me to tell anybody 'not to read Woodman' (after all, he's still my 'favorite author'). However, you're entering a 14 book series at the 5th book. The 1st book in the Nathaniel Drinkwater series is An Eye of the Fleet written in 1981.........trust me, this is where you want to start. Like so many of the 'classic' series, they are 'chronological'.
If you can't find the entire series at your library, I have a set of paperbacks listed under the 'books to loan' thread. Check it out.
80 Winters- Rear-Admiral of the Blue
- Log Entries : 2083
Age : 84
Location : Port Townsend, WA
Joined : 2012-03-09
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
80 Winters wrote:James -
Far be it from me to tell anybody 'not to read Woodman' (after all, he's still my 'favorite author'). However, you're entering a 14 book series at the 5th book. The 1st book in the Nathaniel Drinkwater series is An Eye of the Fleet written in 1981.........trust me, this is where you want to start. Like so many of the 'classic' series, they are 'chronological'.
If you can't find the entire series at your library, I have a set of paperbacks listed under the 'books to loan' thread. Check it out.
I agree - the Drinkwater series is now available in five 'omnibus' editions each with three novels in (two in the last) and this is an excellent way to read them (and ensure you don't inadvertently skip any).
Edit: Having thought about this a little more, the Drinkwater novels, although self-contained, form more of a continuous story than many other series. I've found myself able to pick up Aubery-Maturin, and in my earlier days, Hornblower novels mid-series with no ill-effects, but I'm not sure this would be as possible with the Drinkwater novels. Of course, I read the Drinkwater series through in sequence, with no breaks, so I'm not sure if in fact it would be easier than I think to pick up a novel mid-series... But I can attest to the reading in sequence being most enjoyable.
MattWillis- Masters Mate
- Log Entries : 96
Location : Southampton
. :
Joined : 2012-07-11
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
I have recently finished the fifth omnibus of the Drinkwater series. I liked very much all the sequential volumes, but the last "flashback" stories annoyed me... (In contrast to the comment by "80 winters" that "it was written from start to finish").
Big Joe- Master
- Log Entries : 126
Age : 78
Location : Tel Aviv
Joined : 2010-12-11
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
It's been several years since I last read 'Drinkwater', so I'm not sure when you refer to "flashbacks", unless (hope not to get into 'spoilers' here) they're the "flashbacks" of a dying man in Ebbtide. If so, I've discounted 'memories' when I stated that the series was written in 'chronologicasol order'. I guess I need a bit more information Big Joe.
Also, I haven't read the 'omnibus' versions. Is it possible that they include any of the Drinkwater 'short stories' that Woodman published elsewhere? Because I have read them and 'Yes' they're neither chronological nor, in my view, part of the series.
Also, I haven't read the 'omnibus' versions. Is it possible that they include any of the Drinkwater 'short stories' that Woodman published elsewhere? Because I have read them and 'Yes' they're neither chronological nor, in my view, part of the series.
80 Winters- Rear-Admiral of the Blue
- Log Entries : 2083
Age : 84
Location : Port Townsend, WA
Joined : 2012-03-09
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
Yes, you are right on both accounts.
I did mean the memories of the dying man, which are actually an attempt of the writer to provide some info he felt was missing. It was too much for "memories" without any linkage to storyline we already we are already familiar with. In fact the attempt to fill in some "loopholes" in the history of Drinkwater.
And yes there are in the third part of the omnibus two short stories "The Night Attack" and "The steeple Rock" which are nice stand alone stories, having no impact on the history of Drinkwater.
I did mean the memories of the dying man, which are actually an attempt of the writer to provide some info he felt was missing. It was too much for "memories" without any linkage to storyline we already we are already familiar with. In fact the attempt to fill in some "loopholes" in the history of Drinkwater.
And yes there are in the third part of the omnibus two short stories "The Night Attack" and "The steeple Rock" which are nice stand alone stories, having no impact on the history of Drinkwater.
Big Joe- Master
- Log Entries : 126
Age : 78
Location : Tel Aviv
Joined : 2010-12-11
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
I also enjoyed the short stories and wish the author had provided a few more.
Woodman's Nathaniel Drinkwater was a somewhat 'radical departure', at least for me, from the HNF I'd read to that point. While almost all of the protagonists had faced a 'setback' here or there (well, maybe save Ramage), Nathaniel reminded me of that old 'saw'......."If I didn't have bad luck, I wouldn't have no luck at all". His 'professional life' was a study in adversity, and yet he almost never waivered, but (as we like to say) Pressed On. It truly 'won me' to know that someone could live his life with such 'stiff resolve'. I'm pragmatic, but Nathaniel went far beyond that and when I hear the term 'he was a tarpulin officer...........I'll always see him (and none other).
As for 'his memories', it's said that 'in crisis' prior events can 'flash' before your eyes and I'm not sure how that's suppose to work........(and I'd rather not find out sooner).
Thanks for your thoughts on the Nathaniel Drinkwater series.
Woodman's Nathaniel Drinkwater was a somewhat 'radical departure', at least for me, from the HNF I'd read to that point. While almost all of the protagonists had faced a 'setback' here or there (well, maybe save Ramage), Nathaniel reminded me of that old 'saw'......."If I didn't have bad luck, I wouldn't have no luck at all". His 'professional life' was a study in adversity, and yet he almost never waivered, but (as we like to say) Pressed On. It truly 'won me' to know that someone could live his life with such 'stiff resolve'. I'm pragmatic, but Nathaniel went far beyond that and when I hear the term 'he was a tarpulin officer...........I'll always see him (and none other).
As for 'his memories', it's said that 'in crisis' prior events can 'flash' before your eyes and I'm not sure how that's suppose to work........(and I'd rather not find out sooner).
Thanks for your thoughts on the Nathaniel Drinkwater series.
80 Winters- Rear-Admiral of the Blue
- Log Entries : 2083
Age : 84
Location : Port Townsend, WA
Joined : 2012-03-09
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
I know that the series Drinkwater includes no fewer than 14 books ... unfortunately in Italian only two have been translated. (An Eye of the Fleet,. A King's Cutter). The reading I really liked the character of Daniel I really liked ... no sin to know if there are other translations.
queen katherine- First Lieutenant
- Log Entries : 379
Location : italy
Joined : 2012-07-16
Re: Nathaniel Drinkwater Series
Hello there,
I just finished my 3rd Drinkwater book (A Brig of War) and must say it was a satisfying read - maybe not exactly on par with the POBs that read recently, but still ...
The historical details and the seamanship seem well researched (as far as I can tell) and the characters are well developed. In a way I was pleasently surprised that Nat is still 1st lieutenant - after the first book I feared that, being such a brilliant midshipman, he will be admiral within weeks. Another theme that distinguishes these books from POBs is the bitter enmity between Drinkwater and Morris; this gives the book a gritty edge that is refreshingly different to the Aubrey/Maturin books.
So while I wait for my next POB ration I will follow Mr Drinkwater on his way.
I just finished my 3rd Drinkwater book (A Brig of War) and must say it was a satisfying read - maybe not exactly on par with the POBs that read recently, but still ...
The historical details and the seamanship seem well researched (as far as I can tell) and the characters are well developed. In a way I was pleasently surprised that Nat is still 1st lieutenant - after the first book I feared that, being such a brilliant midshipman, he will be admiral within weeks. Another theme that distinguishes these books from POBs is the bitter enmity between Drinkwater and Morris; this gives the book a gritty edge that is refreshingly different to the Aubrey/Maturin books.
So while I wait for my next POB ration I will follow Mr Drinkwater on his way.
jbaltsar- Able Seaman
- Log Entries : 8
Location : Germany
Joined : 2013-03-27
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
Page 1 of 2
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|
Sat 21 Sep 2024, 17:49 by broughstar
» Doctor in the house
Wed 19 Jun 2024, 04:26 by TonnerreDeBrest
» Julian Stockwin discussion
Sat 13 Apr 2024, 15:17 by pauljm
» Not so much Hornblower....
Wed 03 Apr 2024, 11:21 by broughstar
» Someone Write a Biography of Richard Bolitho!
Thu 12 Oct 2023, 16:51 by 80 Winters
» What would you like the next book to cover?
Thu 12 Oct 2023, 08:19 by Port of Olcott
» Douglas Reeman is dying
Thu 12 Oct 2023, 06:56 by Port of Olcott
» Alexander Kent general discussion.
Thu 05 Oct 2023, 22:51 by jkeffer
» A Horatio Hornblower Short Story as Written by ChatGPT
Tue 11 Apr 2023, 01:00 by TonnerreDeBrest