If you would like to help keep this site going please
AS THIS IS A FREE FORUM ADVERTS FROM THE SERVICE PROVIDER APPEAR TO THE RIGHT OF THIS NOTICE AND THEY ARE NOT CONNECTED TO THIS SITE.
Services Menu
PURCHASE BOOKS DISCUSSEDIf you have heard about a book in this forum and would now like to read it yourself Astrodene has brought together links to purchase them. Links are available for the UK, USA, Canada, Austalia and New Zealand
ASSOCIATED WEB SITE
ARTICLES OF WAR (Forum rules)
FUTURE RELEASES CALENDAR
IMAGES GALLERY
VIDEO CHANNEL
SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER
Similar topics
Search
Latest topics
Latest News on the Web Site
Loading...
Use of Cookies
By using this site, you agree we can set and use cookies. For more details of these cookies and how to disable them, see our cookie policy.Julian Stockwin discussion
+8
80 Winters
conaghan
malchya
reb01501
Corpsman Up
Paul-B
Nowyouseeme123
Astrodene
12 posters
Page 1 of 1
Julian Stockwin discussion
I only recently purchased this series. It was a nice change to start from the perspective of a pressed seaman and then a 'tarpaulin' officer. Putting the first chapter of the next book at the end certainly whet's your appetite for what is to come.
Last edited by Astrodene on Mon 08 Aug 2011, 16:31; edited 1 time in total
Re: Julian Stockwin discussion
I think this will be the series I start reading, as this is the one my local library has the most of. Thanks for your help on my other post though.
Nowyouseeme123- Able Seaman
- Log Entries : 9
Location : USA
Joined : 2010-07-21
Re: Julian Stockwin discussion
A really great series. I discovered "Kydd" a couple of days ago, now I have the complete series as Audiobooks, beautifully read by Christian Rodska, and am looking forward to getting through them all - currently half-way through "Artemis".
Known in the Andrew as coming up "through the haweshole"
Known in the Andrew as coming up "through the haweshole"
Paul-B- Master
- Log Entries : 136
Age : 79
Location : Oxford, England
Joined : 2011-07-19
Re: Julian Stockwin discussion
I have started on this series, and To follow along in Kydd's education and the rumblings of his mess mate is facinating. This has opened up a whole new world of reading. The plight of pressed men is worse than I ever thought.
I thought I understood "Hard Tack" and I knew it was naval staple, but to have it explined in such detail, the elbow to break it up to and the "meat". I am looking forward to many a evening with kydd and his mess mates.
John
I thought I understood "Hard Tack" and I knew it was naval staple, but to have it explined in such detail, the elbow to break it up to and the "meat". I am looking forward to many a evening with kydd and his mess mates.
John
Corpsman Up- Petty Officer
- Log Entries : 40
Age : 78
Location : Winston Salem, North Carolina, USA
Joined : 2011-01-29
Re: Julian Stockwin discussion
Up to "Mutiny" now, but not enjoying it as much as the previous three. The plot seems to me to be getting a little bit silly, and Kydd's womanising is definitely getting boring.
I hope it improves with the next few.
I hope it improves with the next few.
Paul-B- Master
- Log Entries : 136
Age : 79
Location : Oxford, England
Joined : 2011-07-19
Re: Julian Stockwin discussion
It does. I felt there was a bit of a slump around The Admiral's Daughter but it's really got going in the last couple of books.
Re: Julian Stockwin discussion
Great, and thank you. Despite my reservations vis-a-vis "Mutiny" I'm still enjoying the book and the way the character is developing.
I'm finding it interesting the way the various authors develop "pairings" in their characters, with Hornblower - Bush, Bolitho - Herrick, Aubrey - Maturin and now Kydd - Renzi.
I'm finding it interesting the way the various authors develop "pairings" in their characters, with Hornblower - Bush, Bolitho - Herrick, Aubrey - Maturin and now Kydd - Renzi.
Paul-B- Master
- Log Entries : 136
Age : 79
Location : Oxford, England
Joined : 2011-07-19
Re: Julian Stockwin discussion
I was ready to drop it myself during the same period (Mutiny), but as Astrodene says, it definitely did pick up.
reb01501- Vice-Admiral of the Blue
- Log Entries : 670
Age : 69
Location : Florida
Joined : 2008-12-19
Re: Julian Stockwin discussion
I'm going to have to try these again. I read Kydd and Artemis when they first hit the stands, but was not overly impressed. I found them a bit difficult to swallow, actually, so I didn't persevere. They have received sufficient praise here, however, that I just placed a hold on a few of them at my local library. I'll update once I've (re)read them. If I find that I still can't swallow the first two, I'll actually review my reasons here for discussion.
malchya- Masters Mate
- Log Entries : 88
Age : 64
Location : Fort Myers, FL
Joined : 2011-08-14
Re: Julian Stockwin discussion
malchya wrote:I'm going to have to try these again. I read Kydd and Artemis when they first hit the stands, but was not overly impressed. I found them a bit difficult to swallow, actually, so I didn't persevere. They have received sufficient praise here, however, that I just placed a hold on a few of them at my local library. I'll update once I've (re)read them. If I find that I still can't swallow the first two, I'll actually review my reasons here for discussion.
That's good - it's always good to get reasoned reviews and opinions on books.
Paul-B- Master
- Log Entries : 136
Age : 79
Location : Oxford, England
Joined : 2011-07-19
Re: Julian Stockwin discussion
Mr. Stockwin's latest, Conquest, receivied a not unkind but somewhat lukewarm review in the Oct. 29 edition of The Wall Street Journal.
Near the end of the article, the reviewer recommended some other authors, one of whom is my favorite.
But I shall not risk the wrath of the forum by mentioning a particular name.
Near the end of the article, the reviewer recommended some other authors, one of whom is my favorite.
But I shall not risk the wrath of the forum by mentioning a particular name.
conaghan- Masters Mate
- Log Entries : 96
Location : Republic of Northern Virginia
Joined : 2009-05-08
Re: Julian Stockwin discussion
<splutter>
As they say, those who can, do; those who can't, criticize.
As you say, a lukewarm review. Personally I don't think you can compare authors like Lamdin and Stockwin with those from the fairly distant past, like Marryat. Everyone has their own interpretation as to what is good and what is not-so-good, it's very subjective. And I would think that drawing a comparison between Lamdin's work and the "Flashman" novels would probably upset a large number of Lamdin's followers, his writing and his characters are hugely superior to the rather (IMO, of course) shallow ones in the MacDonald Fraser books.
As they say, those who can, do; those who can't, criticize.
As you say, a lukewarm review. Personally I don't think you can compare authors like Lamdin and Stockwin with those from the fairly distant past, like Marryat. Everyone has their own interpretation as to what is good and what is not-so-good, it's very subjective. And I would think that drawing a comparison between Lamdin's work and the "Flashman" novels would probably upset a large number of Lamdin's followers, his writing and his characters are hugely superior to the rather (IMO, of course) shallow ones in the MacDonald Fraser books.
Paul-B- Master
- Log Entries : 136
Age : 79
Location : Oxford, England
Joined : 2011-07-19
Re: Julian Stockwin discussion
This was the 1st HNF series that I joined at its inception with Kydd in 2001. Since its genesis is somewhat different than other series I had read by that time (Aubrey, Hornblower, Drinkwater, Bolitho), where the lead character begins his career as a Midshipman, it was a rough start for me, the reader, as it was new territory. However, that said, I adapted to the scenario and the fact that I had to wait about a year between novels has made it read more like a series of "stand alone" novels. Some of which I enjoyed more than others.
My least enjoyable read was The Admiral's Daughter where I began to wonder if I was reading a Pre-Victorian "boddice-ripper" rather than a "swashbuckler". But since I read to enjoy, I do continue to read them.
My least enjoyable read was The Admiral's Daughter where I began to wonder if I was reading a Pre-Victorian "boddice-ripper" rather than a "swashbuckler". But since I read to enjoy, I do continue to read them.
80 Winters- Rear-Admiral of the Blue
- Log Entries : 2083
Age : 84
Location : Port Townsend, WA
Joined : 2012-03-09
Re: Julian Stockwin discussion
I'd given up on Kydd for the very reasons many mention. Now encouraged to go back and read those after The Admiral's Daughter
leonidas- Midshipman
- Log Entries : 154
Age : 80
Location : Marlborough, New Zealand
Joined : 2011-08-20
Re: Julian Stockwin discussion
I've enjoyed every Kydd book (I have them all in both hard copy and audiobooks) with the one exception of "Mutiny", which I found to have an unbelievable plot and was really not in line with the rest of the Kydd books.
Paul-B- Master
- Log Entries : 136
Age : 79
Location : Oxford, England
Joined : 2011-07-19
Re: Julian Stockwin discussion
ahoy shipmates just to let everyone know julian stockwins new kydd book 20 is the iberian flame. out june of next year.
broughstar- Second Lieutenant
- Log Entries : 277
Age : 65
Location : hull. eastyorkshire uk.
Joined : 2014-12-10
Re: Julian Stockwin discussion
Paul-B wrote:I've enjoyed every Kydd book (I have them all in both hard copy and audiobooks) with the one exception of "Mutiny", which I found to have an unbelievable plot and was really not in line with the rest of the Kydd books.
Yeah, Mutiny was one I could not finish. Halfway through I just skipped to the read end.
Kydd has come to like a sailor's life, he is at this point obsessed with having a career in the Navy, he is probably learning hard for his Master's examination, too. He is not mistreated in the ship at that time, despite pressed, not unsatisfied with his life and options in the RN.
- Spoiler tag added by Reb01501:
- Why would he throw that away and become a ringleader in the great mutiny?
And the way Renzi in the end saves him from hanging for it, that's totally deus ex machina, just big NO from me.
Please use spoiler tags, thanks.
Chromedust- Petty Officer
- Log Entries : 31
Location : Germany
Joined : 2017-01-02
Re: Julian Stockwin discussion
Ahoy shipmates just read on Quartdeck that julian stockwin has a new book out in october. Book 27 Admiral. of the thomas Kydd series. looking forward to that one.
broughstar- Second Lieutenant
- Log Entries : 277
Age : 65
Location : hull. eastyorkshire uk.
Joined : 2014-12-10
Alaric Bond likes this post
Re: Julian Stockwin discussion
Kydd was promoted to post captain in 1804, now the series progressed to 1814. Is 10 years enough to raise the top of the seniority list to be promoted to flag rank? Somehow I find that questionable.
Chromedust- Petty Officer
- Log Entries : 31
Location : Germany
Joined : 2017-01-02
Re: Julian Stockwin discussion
Historically, captains of 1804 had to wait until 1837 to get their flag. The years just after the resumption of the war were a very bad time to be promoted because of all the men who had been made post in the preceding few years. The shortest time for a captain to wait to become admiral was 17-18 years for those such as Nelson who were made post between 1777 and 1779. For a novelist, this is obviously a long time to have his hero stuck in the same rank, so it makes sense to move him along more quickly. C.S. Forester did the same thing with Hornblower.
pauljm- Masters Mate
- Log Entries : 82
Location : Canada
Joined : 2013-11-18
Alaric Bond, 80 Winters and broughstar like this post
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|
Sat 21 Sep 2024, 17:49 by broughstar
» Doctor in the house
Wed 19 Jun 2024, 04:26 by TonnerreDeBrest
» Julian Stockwin discussion
Sat 13 Apr 2024, 15:17 by pauljm
» Not so much Hornblower....
Wed 03 Apr 2024, 11:21 by broughstar
» Someone Write a Biography of Richard Bolitho!
Thu 12 Oct 2023, 16:51 by 80 Winters
» What would you like the next book to cover?
Thu 12 Oct 2023, 08:19 by Port of Olcott
» Douglas Reeman is dying
Thu 12 Oct 2023, 06:56 by Port of Olcott
» Alexander Kent general discussion.
Thu 05 Oct 2023, 22:51 by jkeffer
» A Horatio Hornblower Short Story as Written by ChatGPT
Tue 11 Apr 2023, 01:00 by TonnerreDeBrest