If you would like to help keep this site going please

AS THIS IS A FREE FORUM ADVERTS FROM THE SERVICE PROVIDER APPEAR TO THE RIGHT OF THIS NOTICE AND THEY ARE NOT CONNECTED TO THIS SITE.
Services Menu
PURCHASE BOOKS DISCUSSED
If you have heard about a book in this forum and would now like to read it yourself Astrodene has brought together links to purchase them. Links are available for the UK, USA, Canada, Austalia and New Zealand
ASSOCIATED WEB SITE
ARTICLES OF WAR (Forum rules)
FUTURE RELEASES CALENDAR
IMAGES GALLERY
VIDEO CHANNEL
SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER
Similar topics
    Search
     
     

    Display results as :
     

     


    Rechercher Advanced Search

    Latest topics
    » Free audio books!
    Decline of a series EmptyThu 02 Apr 2020, 07:28 by Alaric Bond

    » New member on the deck
    Decline of a series EmptyWed 01 Apr 2020, 22:35 by Oliéric

    » Douglas Reeman
    Decline of a series EmptyTue 10 Mar 2020, 07:41 by Alaric Bond

    » Eighteen Twelve (1812)
    Decline of a series EmptyFri 21 Feb 2020, 18:06 by 80 Winters

    » Other Forester Books
    Decline of a series EmptySun 16 Feb 2020, 08:44 by Alaric Bond

    » Honour Bound
    Decline of a series EmptyFri 07 Feb 2020, 15:29 by Odissee

    » To the Eastern Seas
    Decline of a series EmptySat 18 Jan 2020, 17:04 by Chromedust

    » O'Brian talking books
    Decline of a series EmptySat 12 Oct 2019, 13:35 by elfridaauston87

    » Balkan Glory
    Decline of a series EmptySun 29 Sep 2019, 17:15 by 80 Winters

    Latest News on the Web Site
    Loading...
    Use of Cookies
    By using this site, you agree we can set and use cookies. For more details of these cookies and how to disable them, see our cookie policy.

    Decline of a series

    Go down

    Decline of a series Empty Decline of a series

    Post by malchya on Mon 15 Aug 2011, 18:55

    Let me open this by stating that my favorite piece of NHF is Kent's Enemy in Sight. Sloop of War would be about 7 or 8 on my top ten and Signal: Close Action would get an honorable mention.

    In point of fact, I've enjoyed all of Mr. Reeman's work, more or less, either under his own flag or that of Alexander Kent. But I've enjoyed them less and less as time gets on. They begin to feel somewhat as if they were after thoughts. Bolitho particularly feels as if he has grown into a caricature of himself. What a shame.

    In the earlier books, such as the ones mentioned above, I was able to put aside my OCD nature and enjoy the stories despite such things as carronades firing exploding shells and 18 gun sloops mounting 32 pdr bow chasers. I could even overlook a three masted vessel with nothing left standing but "a scrap set on the cro'jack" tacking. The stories and characters were just that compelling. But, as the series progressed, the characters began to take on certain aspects of cardboard. The stories stopped being rousing adventures of the sea and became little more than poorly disguised romance novels. And when they attempt to convey the nautical setting it is almost as if he has mined past works for the descriptions, just moving a few phrases around here and there.

    It's sad. Rather like watching an old and beloved friend move into the final stages of senility.
    malchya
    malchya
    Masters Mate
    Masters Mate

    Log Entries : 88
    Age : 59
    Location : Fort Myers, FL
    Joined : 2011-08-14

    Back to top Go down

    Decline of a series Empty Re: Decline of a series

    Post by reb01501 on Mon 15 Aug 2011, 19:11

    Not much to disagree with here, although I still managed to make my way through the entire series. My major criticism remains the mirroring of Bolitho's life with Nelson's.

    _______________________________
    Bob
    Decline of a series Userba10
    reb01501
    reb01501
    Vice-Admiral of the Blue
    Vice-Admiral of the Blue

    Log Entries : 663
    Age : 64
    Location : Florida
    Joined : 2008-12-19

    Back to top Go down

    Decline of a series Empty Re: Decline of a series

    Post by Joolz on Tue 16 Aug 2011, 16:32

    I am currently working my way through Smalley's "Expedient" series but am already wondering if he will sustain my enthusiasm till the end, even though it is only a short series. Absolutely love the first 2, but am unsure how it will develop from there.

    I first encountered Reeman in the 60s/70s, but neither as Reeman nor Kent has he fully captured my imagination. I have to date read only the first 2 Bolitho books, and have little inclination to explore further as yet.
    Joolz
    Joolz
    Master
    Master

    Log Entries : 145
    Location : UK
    Joined : 2011-07-12

    Back to top Go down

    Decline of a series Empty Re: Decline of a series

    Post by Paul-B on Fri 19 Aug 2011, 10:44

    Personally I like Reeman's books, I've recently finished reading his "HMS Saracen" and enjoyed it. I doubt, though, that such a prolific author can maintain a particularly high standard throughout, certainly the Bolitho series is, to my mind, flawed this way.

    Incidentally I'm going to be getting a copy of "Coronach" by his partner, Kimberley, which has received some good reviews. Not HNF but then, we are allowed to read other stuff occasionally Smile
    Paul-B
    Paul-B
    Master
    Master

    Log Entries : 136
    Age : 75
    Location : Oxford, England
    Joined : 2011-07-19

    Back to top Go down

    Decline of a series Empty Re: Decline of a series

    Post by Astrodene on Fri 19 Aug 2011, 11:20

    @Paul-B wrote:I've recently finished reading his "HMS Saracen" and enjoyed it.

    I remember reading that back in the 60's when it first came out. Looks like another trip to that pile of boxes up in the loft is called for.................... Very Happy

    _______________________________
    David
    Decline of a series Userba10
    http://historicnavalfiction.com *** http://www.astrodene.com
    Astrodene
    Astrodene
    Admiral of the Fleet
    Admiral of the Fleet

    Log Entries : 2863
    Age : 68
    Location : Essex, England
    Joined : 2008-08-21

    http://www.historicnavalfiction.com

    Back to top Go down

    Decline of a series Empty Re: Decline of a series

    Post by malchya on Fri 19 Aug 2011, 11:41

    I picked H.M.S. Saracen up at a used book store about two weeks ago and re read it. It had been the first non - Kent book I had read by Reeman, so I had fond memories of it. Upon rereading I fully understood why! This was a really good read.

    As an aside, I picked up "Battlecruiser", one of his more recent efforts at the same time. All I can say is "Don't bother." The two books read back to back really make the point of my original post.
    malchya
    malchya
    Masters Mate
    Masters Mate

    Log Entries : 88
    Age : 59
    Location : Fort Myers, FL
    Joined : 2011-08-14

    Back to top Go down

    Decline of a series Empty Re: Decline of a series

    Post by 80 Winters on Sun 18 Mar 2012, 18:36

    I started reading this series back in 2001 in paperback with Richard Bolitho-Midshipman(1975) and finished (I hope) the series with In the Kings Name(2011) a book which was advertised "to be published" 2 years before (I'm told that Reeman had a period of illness and/or was finishing another book in his 20th century HNF series first).

    The series held my rapt attention up until "they Nelson'd him" and then it began to drift as in "looking for a wind". While it's not all bad after that, the series fell back to "middle of the pack" in my ratings. I did enjoy Band of Brothers(2005) because, I too wanted to know "what ever happened to Martin Dancer". Douglas Reeman must be pushing 90 by now, so I say, "Mr. Reeman, you've given us some great HNF and for much of what we have received.....we're grateful".


    Last edited by 80 Winters on Mon 19 Mar 2012, 15:06; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : spelling correction)
    80 Winters
    80 Winters
    Rear-Admiral of the Blue
    Rear-Admiral of the Blue

    Log Entries : 2002
    Age : 79
    Location : Port Townsend, WA
    Joined : 2012-03-09

    Back to top Go down

    Decline of a series Empty Re: Decline of a series

    Post by Paul-B on Sun 18 Mar 2012, 18:56

    Douglas was born in 1924
    Paul-B
    Paul-B
    Master
    Master

    Log Entries : 136
    Age : 75
    Location : Oxford, England
    Joined : 2011-07-19

    Back to top Go down

    Decline of a series Empty Re: Decline of a series

    Post by 80 Winters on Mon 19 Mar 2012, 03:42

    Just spent a few hours doing a brief reprise of this series later books (post Richard). While my comments above are still valid, I will add that, at least for me, the series could have ended, very smoothly, with no strings hanging, at the conclusion of Hearts of Oak when Adam marries Lowenna, as a host of the primary characters are there and there is "closure" with respect to the Napoleanic Wars as (and I quote): "Capitaine Luc Marchand smiled and shook his head. 'He is my friend.' It was enough".........................(and that was enough for me)
    80 Winters
    80 Winters
    Rear-Admiral of the Blue
    Rear-Admiral of the Blue

    Log Entries : 2002
    Age : 79
    Location : Port Townsend, WA
    Joined : 2012-03-09

    Back to top Go down

    Decline of a series Empty Re: Decline of a series

    Post by burtbarnard on Wed 03 Oct 2012, 13:34

    Mr. Reeman is getting up there in age, and I would love it if he would finish the series. Maybe one last adventure with Adam or maybe the story of when Richard first went to sea in the Manxman and then a epilogue telling about Adams descendants who stayed in the Royal Navy.
    burtbarnard
    burtbarnard
    Able Seaman
    Able Seaman

    Log Entries : 6
    Age : 50
    Location : Salt Lake City, Utah
    Joined : 2012-10-02

    Back to top Go down

    Decline of a series Empty Re: Decline of a series

    Post by Sponsored content


    Sponsored content


    Back to top Go down

    Back to top

    - Similar topics

     
    Permissions in this forum:
    You cannot reply to topics in this forum